Review: Pencil Eyeliners

Following the liquid eyeliner review, here's another review on eyeliners but this time round it's for pencil eyeliner. 

Sequence form top to bottom:

#1-#3 are all brown eyeliners

#1 Heavy Rotation Perfect Eyeliner N

#2 BoBo Eyeliner (From Taiwan)

#3 K Palette 1 Day Tattoo Real Lasting Eyepencil

#4-#6 are all black eyeliners

#4 K Palette 1 Day Tattoo Real Lasting Eyepencil

#5 BoBo Eyeliner (From Taiwan)

#6 MAC Kohl Pencil

The eyeliners are also drawn in the same sequence as above. So let's get on with the water,smudge test :)

Everything seems perfect after I ran my hand through running water. Nothing smudge or looks like it's going to smudge.

So, I rested my finger on top of my hand and pulled it across and this was what happened! 

As you can see, the ones that smudged the least were from K Palette, followed by Bobo and so on. Similar to the liquid eyeliner review, K Palette is the winner for being the most waterproof and smudge proof eyeliner! You can get them easily from any Watsons at S$19.90 each. 

From my personal experience, K Palette's eyeliners gave me the least problems. I have quite oily lids so I really had a hard time finding one that does not smudge. I used to look like a zombie/panda/whatever you call it at the end of the day when my eyeliner smudged like nobody's business. So happy that I have found one that is good although I do not detest or restrict myself to not use other brands. I would still love to try more out. Who knows? I might find more than one that I like :)

All products are bought by myself and not sponsored. If they are, I would indicate.